Why Is It So Hard to Be Ordinary?

It’s what most of us are, most of the time. Shouldn’t it be enough?

May 22, 2026

Illustration by Josie Norton

You’re reading Open Questions, Joshua Rothman’s weekly column exploring what it means to be human.

Your window is closing.

Don’t lose these views. Get full access for ~~$2.50~~ $1 a week for one year, plus a free tote. Cancel or pause anytime.

See Offers

Already a subscriber? Sign In

Unlock this story for just ~~$2.50~~ $1 a week for 1 year. Subscribe »

New Yorker Favorites

A scientist with a Ph.D. from Harvard fatally shot three of her colleagues. Then revelations about her family history came to light.
Play Catalogues, our new daily game, and bring order to the chaos.
A Marilyn Monroe-J.F.K. mystery.
The paperboy’s secret.
When Ebola arrived in America.
Are Disney adults the happiest debtors on earth?

Joshua Rothman, a staff writer, authors the weekly column Open Questions. He has been with the magazine since 2012.

More:Philosophy Life Mediocrity Parenting

The Lede

The Men Who Lie About Their Height

From guys trying to make it past women’s six-foot filter on dating apps to basketball players hoping to get drafted, men continue to exaggerate how tall they are.

By Brady Brickner-Wood

Page-Turner

What We’re Reading This Summer: Pocket Reads

New Yorker writers name their favorite short books.

By Rachel Syme, Sarah Larson, Jennifer Wilson, Kyle Chayka, Jon Allsop, Naomi Fry, Helen Rosner, Alexandra Schwartz, and Hua Hsu

Under Review

Why the Best Writing Advice Is Often the Weirdest

“Three six five,” a new collection of writing exercises, belongs to a venerable tradition of goofy, esoteric, and avant-garde guides to unlocking the creative mind.

By David O’Neill

Fault Lines

Can A.I. Produce Writing That We Actually Want to Read?

I recently created a simple test, which convinced me that the answer is no.

By Jay Caspian Kang

The Sporting Scene

The Knicks Take the Series—Seize the Joy!

A fan’s late-night notes.

By David Remnick

Reflections

How Problematic Is Patriotism?

National pride in America has plummeted in the Trump era. Is it worth trying to salvage?

By Arthur Krystal

Progress Report

Why “Book-Shaming” Won’t Solve the Children’s Literacy Crisis

The nation’s official advocate for children’s books says most of them are “crud.” But matters of literary quality don’t explain why kids aren’t reading.

By Jessica Winter

Books

When Did White-Collar Work Start to Look So Bleak?

In the nineteen-eighties, an office job promised security and fulfillment. For graduates starting careers today, the prospect is often tinged with dread.

By Molly Fischer

What We’re Reading

Welcome to What We’re Reading

From the What We’re Reading newsletter: kicking off our new books newsletter with a few recommendations.

By Namara Smith

The Lede

Lessons in Fanhood from the Knicks

Grown men weep, on the way to the N.B.A. Finals.

By Vinson Cunningham

The New Yorker Interview

Ben Gibbard on Breaking Out of Lyrical Jail

The front man of Death Cab for Cutie discusses resisting nostalgia, working through loss, and why he can’t get away with singing like Matt Berninger or Thom Yorke.

By Hanif Abdurraqib

The Lede

The Changing Face of “Authenticity” in Politics

What Graham Platner’s scandal-plagued Senate run says about a tired cliché.

By Jon Allsop

New Yorker Favorites

The Goings On Newsletter