After the people behind the show made sure to encourage them a whole bunch back in the day, they could have squashed down on them but they didn't and Hasbro certainly didn't mind making money from the bronies so no one is clean among the adults (Bronies, show making people and Hasbro executives)
>be lauren faust
>be on deviantart for years
>base a pony franchise generation on sailor moon
>everyone is surprised it somehow turns into a bestiality harem anime
They made a very limp-wristed attempt at one point, but it never went beyond a few DMCAs of community posts/sites, and they ended up bending the knee and going back on all of it not long after.
Hasbro sucks for a number of reasons (their treatment of GI Joe would be one) but they've actually been generally pretty tolerant of insanely awful abuse of their IP, particularly the heinous porn.
On July 29th 2026, Caleb Hammer would release a new episode in his acclaimed Financial Audit series.
1:33:39
This sent shockwaves around certain communities, because this is not just a random shitter off the street. This is the person who created an extremely famous shitty MLP "grimdark" creepypasta gore thing, known as Lil Miss Rarity, in 2014; garnering nearly ten million views in that time.
2:57
One could expect that he may have been able to parlay that success into anything noteworthy since, but given he is now on Financial Audit, weeeell... you can see how that turned out. a
Let me weave you the tale of this episode! Brief facts rundown:
Jay is a fat 37-year-old 'artist' born on November 17th, 1987 currently living in his obese enabler mother's home in Paradise, California.
He draws porn for his Discord community who pay him for goon material, claiming he also does 40 commissioned drawings a month.
He is a wannabe musician, likely using AI
He also attempted to train an AI to mimic his artstyle so that he could do even less work.
He is a wannabe gamedev and musician. He also made some gay Binding of Isaac mod OC called "Bestia".
He self-describes himself as a brony and a furry. He produced comics and artwork that became popular within the pony fandom.
He attended conventions, sold prints and merchandise, and was active enough to form ongoing online and in-person connections in the broader pony and furry circles.
As mentioned, he continues to work primarily through Discord, taking commissions, and identifies as a furry artist whose personal character/fursona is a deerwolf. His current paid work centers on anthropomorphic / furry characters, frequently explicit or “horny” themed, at roughly $200–$400 per piece.
Funny facts:
He got catfished by edating a tranny for nine years. He was peer pressured by the tranny into also briefly trooning out. (~17:12)
The troon didn't even tell him that he was a troon for the first 3 years of the relationship because they never even voicechatted prior.
He was convinced to stay with the troon because he wanted to be a 'good ally'.
He paid for the troon's HRT for a significant length of time.
"Lil Miss Rarity" was a 'creepypasta project' that honestly appears more like a look into the creator's depraved psyche more than anything genuinely artistic.
He has debt, lives off doordash and overspends on all sorts of slop and Steam games.
He has a fear of ever recieving a blowjob because he doesn't want his penis bitten.
He was 'traumatized' at age 11 because his school apparently brought out rape survivors to talk about rape (????)
He almost got laid, but found out last-minute the girl in his bed had an STD and he decided to tell her to leave
All of the above is more or less revealed while Caleb is screaming calling him a retarded idiot.
The episode turns dark when it turns to discussing his predilections for drawing depictions of what Caleb and his team visually identify as the underaged, within the contexts of My Little Pony, furry art, and weebshit.
As expected, Jay pulls out the "petite" and "thousand years old" defense at regular intervals (~40:25)
He claims he stopped doing this in 2018-19, buuut... the jury is out on that!
He claims that he only did this for money - he stated that when someone is “desperate enough for money in that moment,” they will take the commission, “especially if you can draw.” He described talking directly with each client on Discord to clarify exactly what they wanted, distinguishing between “strange fetish” requests and more personal ones (like one time he apparently was asked to draw a pedophile's real-life sister, which he claims he escalated to the police, and also claims to do that whenever applicable).
His cope is that he never gooned to what he drew - he did it explicitly for money. He attempts to position himself as morally above, yet still actively providing said content.
I want to hone in on something, because it is both extremely disconcertingly fucked up, and also kinda fucking funny.
Jay defends "foalcon" - porn art of the explicitly underage characters in My Little Pony - directly to Caleb's face. Caleb, obviously, fights back on this, but Jay's counterargument is, verbatim, "I am not giving human rights to horse kids."
0:04
For reference, the guy here explicitly names Sweetie Belle as a character he has drawn porn of, and continues to attempt defending, to Caleb.
0:08
That's cool! Anyways, here is the longtime voice actress (2010-2019) for said character, Claire Corlett, who voiced this child character spanning her real-life age of 11 to 20, explicitly stating in an interview last year with the drama YouTuber Cope and Seethe that the people who drew/draw and jerk off to this are pedophiles. Lol, lmao.
1:26
(This was said during an interview specifically regarding BronyFandont/Bonk, someone also extensively covered by Cope and Seethe, and who probably deserves his own effortpost at some point).
Anyways! Caleb also pulls up some sort of grooming allegations against Jay partway through the show. It is inconclusive on what actually happened and Caleb insinuates that the accuser might also be a pedophile too. I have been unable to secure whatever it was that Caleb's team found. It appears Caleb had found a counterdocument produced by Jay rather than the actual accusation too. If someone finds it, I would be interested to see more about it!
I membered to Caleb Hammer so that I could watch and archive the paywalled content about this guy too.
The Post-Show:
23:13
Highlights: One of Caleb's producers calls him out for trying to pull a fast-one on them; he wanted to use his online handle and tried to swindle them into using something tied to him. Caleb and his team yell and berate him rightfully for being a leech to his parents and attempt to get him to call the transgender ex. They continue bullying him for a bit, and then the episode ends once Jay claims that "Chris Hansen agrees with me on the legality of drawings."
Behind The Scenes:
10:32
Highlights: He tells yet more embarrassing stories, like the time he nearly died of dehydration and heatstroke. He dreams of a girl commissioning him for furry porn art that starts a relationship and a romantic dinner. He also recalls how he attempted to get Tara Strong, the voice of Twilight Sparkle, to sign his art of her character anthropomorphized with huge tits. Apparently she really liked it, signed a bunch of his art, and this boosted his sales because he advertised it as "Tara-approved". I am unable to find actual proof of this claim of his, but I may not be looking hard enough.@Spectatefound a picture of them at a con.
After the episode aired, Jay was surprised that Caleb and his team see him as a content cow to milk and call a pedophile.
I have made a follow-up post regarding his reactions within his public Discord server, in which he completely melts down, breaks his NDA with Caleb Hammer, and threatens lawfare, before then proceeding to flee his home while posting several images and video from his new location to his PUBLIC DISCORD SERVER. I also archived his appearance on the sister-show Dating Audit.
Jay Discord Logs: watch in real-time as he realizes this was not a good idea.
At first, he seems really into the episode! All in good fun!
Jay responds to the allegation levied by one of Caleb's producers doing the postshow about the tranny name. His trans name was apparently "Jynkx".
Some alleged BTS. ...
This entire thing honestly reminds me of a broader phenomena that has intrigued me for a while. Prior to the G6 announcement, I was actually looking into the Brony sphere a little while ago, because I found that it was surprisingly active for a community whose show ended seven years ago. I did some expeditioning and had found this video from someone who was a kid that grew up watching the show:
Which verbalizes something extremely fascinating: My Little Pony was a defacto Internet Ground Zero for both EPI (Early-Porn Introduction) and Early-Gore Introduction. This outcome makes a lot of sense - it was a fandom born from 4chan ironypoisoned culture. It was very much one-of-a-kind, and it had the especially cursed fate of having an intermingling adult and child fanbase, which at this point in the Internet, was apparently a really difficult thing to properly place barriers on. This led to all sorts of insane shit happening in brony spaces that don't even really get brought up anymore, despite them being fucking insane and still having ramifications on people to this very day.
There is a sequence in this video where he brings on anonymous interviewees to talk about their experience having their childhood innocence fucked up and warped by the content they saw as children; one of the girls explicitly being a victim of EPI. Specifically, there was/is an epidemic of these creepypasta, gore, and sexual content pony videos not having any proper agegating - several persisting even to this very day - which on the videos that still have comments enabled, are literally full of THOUSANDS of people talking about how this fucked up content either traumatized them or fucked up their brain chemistry, as said videos often used bait and switch to lure kids in.
I had been looking into a couple of these figures and would like to mention them now, since even in the history of this thread, mentions have been subpar and lacking.
MisterDavie / MisterDavey was an animator active in the scene, and his claim to fame was creating fan animations of MLP, mimicking the show's artstyle, and bait-and-switching with both thumbnail and video contents to sudden extreme graphic gore. His content received a total number of views in the tens of millions. His most famous works in the fandom zeitgeist appear to have been "Cupcakes HD" and "Smile HD" in which the children's characters are brutally murdered in graphic, gory ways. Somehow, these videos, to this day, are not age-restricted. https://mlpfanart.fandom.com/wiki/MisterDavey
The folk legend around him was that he was a secret disgruntled Hasbro animator, which was thought at the time because he closely mimicked the show's artstyle (spoiler, but this probably isn't true). He also was so prolific, Hasbro personally stepped in and tried to rape him:
And he hasn't been heard from since in an entire decade.
In a way, this reminds me of Shadman. Obviously not one-to-one, but this was an edgy Newgrounds provocateur who was defended at the time, but is responsible for an extremely large-scale introduction of gore to an audience of quite literal children on YouTube who were trying to watch videos about a children's horse show. He deliberately used bait-and-switch thumbnails to lure in children, mimicked the show's artstyle, even included the show's official Network watermark in some of said animations to make kids think they were watching a clip, only for it to be interrupted with dramatic gore. Check the comments on either his two remaining videos or his reuploads and you will see firsthand this is not an exageration. This is again also a section in the "My Little Trauma" video.
I reiterate: this wasn't a case of trolling adult men "bronies", this was a case of mass traumatizing children.
After Hasbro tried to rape him, he seemingly fucked off from the Internet. I was curious to see if I could phonebook him, because I'm quite curious to see who the type of person this guy was to do this on YouTube. If he didn't fuck off in 2016 (peak Newgrounds 'edge' era), I believe he would have garnered scrutiny from places like us in a similar vein to Shad.
I found some interesting videos basically attempting to do this. The best one is undoubtedly the following, as he digs through Wayback Machine to find his oldest Internet footprints, history of claiming to work for various animation studios, and his last known Internet activity + a failed Patreon:
12:44
And another, though this one is more fluff:
7:05
Me and @notorietus did attempt to dox him, but were unable to do so with precision. It remains to be seen whether he actually was a legit corporate animator, or what he went off to do post-2016.
"Toma Yatsuhiro" brought up zero results, but Joseph Young does coincidentally match this IMDB profile of a Hollywood VFX producer and animator. I am refraining from posting more about that specific lead because that very well may be a faildox and I absolutely do not want to misattribute something of this scale to an innocent party; but if anyone else has more information, please bring it forward!
Here is also another early porn introduction and early gore introduction animator from the time - again on YouTube and whom did not restrict anything, who garnered tens of millions of views from children: tiarawhy. Clip of segment from the trauma video:
9:28
Basically, he drew both gore and just barely softcore porn directly on YouTube, unagegated. He also does not have the excuse of Davey having gone inactive a decade ago; he is STILL AROUND! a
Here is also another early porn introduction and early gore introduction animator from the time - again on YouTube and whom did not restrict anything, who garnered tens of millions of views from children: tiarawhy.
You inspired me to look a little deeper into this guy, and I have a bit more info to share:
Looking up nsegative@gmail.com on breach.vip gives us this:
The password "fun37pie" collides with a few more accounts:
I was unable to confirm that riodriwi@docmail.cz was him, but this reveals another email and name...
I know bronies read this thread - I saw you guys having your own side-discussion about the show and fandom after my prior post in this thread got featured and revived it. If you guys have any other insane stories or bad people that deserve another eye on them in 2026, please feel free to suggest them. I know we already have extensive coverage of guys like Lily Orchard and Flufflepuff, but it feels like there's still some gems just sitting out in the open, waiting for us to find them again.
This community is such a fascinating microchasm of early-mid 2010s Internet. And the effects of it are still felt to this very day. Hell, a huge segment of the online 'cartoon community' is downstream from these goddamn horses.
I like how the financial part of the financial show lasts approximately 3 minutes before the entire thing just completely devolves into two fat neckbeards screaming at each other over cartoon loli horse pussy.
I forgot that bronies were still a thing, wasn't that show canceled a while ago. Even back when the show was popular it was so creepy that a bunch of gross autistic men were obsessed with a show for little girls
I like how the financial part of the financial show lasts approximately 3 minutes before the entire thing just completely devolves into two fat neckbeards screaming at each other over cartoon loli horse pussy.
Caleb Hammer's show is more him yelling at people and calling them retards than an actual financial help show. I kinda doubt most of the guests are real since why the fuck would anyone agree to go on it unless they were getting paid?
Ya know.....its scarily fuckin serendipitous this thread coming up on featured again as literally in the past half hour, my toddler niece who has as of this past month discovered MLP and forced me to watch it with her whenever I babysit/hang out with her, demanded that I buy her some MLP dolls during a facetime call. Upon checking to see how much they cost and realising how horrifyingly inflated the prices are because of the fucking brony demographic I felt the immediate need to shriek my rage at the heavens so I loaded up the farms and saw fresh brony shit had hit the pentagon
Ya know.....its scarily fuckin serendipitous this thread coming up on featured again as literally in the past half hour, my toddler niece who has as of this past month discovered MLP and forced me to watch it with her whenever I babysit/hang out with her, demanded that I buy her some MLP dolls during a facetime call. Upon checking to see how much they cost and realising how horrifyingly inflated the prices are because of the fucking brony demographic I felt the immediate need to shriek my rage at the heavens so I loaded up the farms and saw fresh brony shit had hit the pentagon
a
...
x 6 
what a fucking nuke of a feature to start my morning with regardless
