Skip to main content

Whales are dying, but it’s not because of wind farms

Whales are washing up along the east coast of the US. Offshore wind opponents blame future wind farms. Experts see a different threat.

A closeup of a whale’s tail on the sand at a beach, with yellow caution tape surrounding it.
A closeup of a whale’s tail on the sand at a beach, with yellow caution tape surrounding it.
The tail of a dead beached whale is seen on Rockaway beach on December 13th, 2022, in the Queens borough of New York City.
| Photo by Bryan Bedder / Getty Images

Whales are dying, but it’s not because of wind farms

Whales are washing up along the east coast of the US. Offshore wind opponents blame future wind farms. Experts see a different threat.

Justine Calma
is a senior science reporter covering energy and the environment with more than a decade of experience. She is also the host of Hell or High Water: When Disaster Hits Home, a podcast from Vox Media and Audible Originals.

Beaches have become makeshift necropsy labs along the shores of New York and New Jersey. An alarming number of whales are washing up along the east coast of the US. And when they do, a team of researchers arrives at the scene to hunt for clues pointing to a cause of death.

They start by examining the outside of the body. Are there teeth marks from an attack? Or are there telltale signs of an accident with a ship: gashes from propellers, rust that has rubbed off from the vessel, broken bones or flesh that’s been pushed in from the impact?

“I can certainly tell you from my experience, I’ve seen a lot of ship-struck whales,” says Joy Reidenberg, who’s typically on call for such investigations.

“I’ve seen a lot of ship-struck whales”

The victims have become posthumous poster children for opponents of offshore wind energy — despite a lack of any evidence that wind farms are to blame. That distracts from very real risks shipping vessels pose to whales navigating US shorelines, experts say.

More than 30 dead whales have washed ashore on the east coast since December 31st, many of them in New Jersey and New York. It can be incredibly difficult to figure out a cause of death — a grim task scientists often volunteer to help out with on their own time. And while they’re not always able to find the answers they’re looking for, what they see time and again is evidence of run-ins with ships.

“The data seems to be pointing overwhelmingly to ship strikes,” says Reidenberg, a comparative anatomist at the Icahn School of Medicine whose research focuses on marine mammals.

Reidenberg volunteers for New York’s Atlantic Marine Conservation Society and New Jersey’s Marine Mammal Stranding Center, organizations authorized to respond to stranded whales.

Subscribe to The Verge to continue reading.