Advertisement
Advertisement
Business Insider

I'm a French mom raising my daughter in Florida. I wasn't prepared for how differently people parent here.

Virginie Romary
5 min read
Add Yahoo on Google
the author and her daughter sitting on the hood of a baby blue classic car
The author is from France, and moved to the US 10 years ago.Courtesy of Virginie Romary
  • I moved from Paris to Florida 10 years ago.

  • I'm raising my daughter, now 8, in the US.

  • I wasn't prepared for how differently people parent here.

I grew up in France, and before moving to Fort Lauderdale 10 years ago, I had no idea how different it was to raise a child in the US. I tried to make some adjustments to fit better into American culture, but there were some French parenting norms I just couldn't let go of.

My daughter learned table manners at age 3

For the French, what we eat is as important as how we eat. When my daughter was 3, I taught her to sit up while eating without resting her elbows on the table, holding her fork in one hand and her knife in the other. Being French, I see it as a way to show respect to others. I also find it more pleasant to be around people who eat nicely.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Every time I go to the restaurant, I notice that American parents have a more casual approach. My daughter doesn't understand why other kids are allowed to eat with their fingers and chew with an open mouth, but she isn't. I stand firm on the matter because I believe she will have better opportunities in life if she has good manners.

I don't give her extra screen time or reward her for chores

My daughter, now 8, has a lot of spare time after school and on the weekends to do what she wants, including screen time. However, I set clear limits. She can only watch 45 minutes of television daily. She doesn't have a phone or a tablet, and she isn't allowed to use mine to access the internet. In the pediatrician's waiting room, she is the one holding a book instead of a phone.

I don't reward her with additional screen time, even for good grades at school, whereas her friends are granted more time on their devices. In fact, I never offer her incentives to do anything, though it seems Americans are more likely to do so.

My daughter told me that her friends receive money for setting the table or putting away the dishes. I prefer to establish clear boundaries. I explained to her that it is her responsibility to help at home and that there is no incentive to do so. She knows that if she doesn't help, I will be disappointed, which she doesn't want. Now, she sets the table without me asking.

Advertisement
Advertisement

At gatherings, I have noticed that some parents regard me with curiosity when they see my daughter sitting quietly next to me, while their kids are racing around the tables. They probably perceive me as too strict.

The author's daughter standing near a body of water, holding an American flag in one hand and a French flag in another.
The author experienced culture shock when moving to the US.Courtesy of Virginie Romary

I avoid over-praising my daughter

I admire the time and energy that my American friends devote to fostering their children's self-esteem. They never miss sports practice to encourage and support them, whereas I just drop my kid off and go do something else.

At the library, I regularly witness young children making ordinary scribbles. Their American moms always compliment them as if they were Picasso: "That's fantastic; you're very talented!"

I don't give overly positive feedback to my child, especially when she rushes through a drawing with minimal effort. When she returns from school with an A, I just say, "Good job on your hard work," while many of her classmates get gifts and lots of praise from their moms.

Advertisement
Advertisement

I want my daughter to be confident, too, but I worry that overconfidence can inhibit self-reflection and improvement. To help her believe in herself, I focus on independence.

Overparenting is not for me; I prefer to rely on independence

Ever since she was very little, I have tried to encourage my daughter's independence and pushed her to do things on her own. I think that builds her confidence, and it also allows me to have more time for myself.

At six months, she slept alone in her bed without waking us through the night. At 4, she tied her shoelaces and got dressed for school by herself, which gave me more time to get ready. At 8, she manages her homework without my supervision. It teaches her to be responsible for her actions. If she doesn't complete it, she receives a failing grade, something she strongly dislikes.

Now that I live in the US, I realize that helicopter parenting really exists. Many parents here supervise their children rather than let them do things on their own. My friends closely monitor homework, even when it overwhelms them and their kids.

Advertisement
Advertisement

In our competitive society, I understand parents' desire to help, especially with assignments. However, that approach doesn't suit me. I prefer to spend the time I dedicate to my child at the beach, laughing, rather than reciting multiplication tables.

There is no right way to parent, and raising a kid in a country with another culture has not always been straightforward for me. But our family has so far found a balance between French and American parenting that works for us, although my daughter feels a stronger connection to American culture.

Read the original article on Business Insider

Up next
Business Insider

My daughter is in college and almost never asks me for money. Instead, she works on campus and budgets $100 a week.

Jenna Brooks
4 min read
Add Yahoo on Google
Money lessons from older Americans who learned the hard way
Money lessons from older Americans who learned the hard way
Scroll back up to restore default view.
  • I realized my college-age daughter never asked me to send her money.

  • When I asked her why, she told me she budgets and lives off $100 a week.

  • She told me she likes the independence of paying for herself.

My daughter was four months into her freshman year of college when I realized she had never asked me for any money.

I'd paid for Sarina's housing, meal plan, and books, and put $100 on her account for laundry and incidentals at the beginning of the year. But that was it.

Advertisement
Advertisement

It didn't occur to me until another mom posted a joke about how, every time her kid called "just to say I love you," somewhere in the conversation, there would be a shakedown for money.

Lots of fellow parents joked around in the comments about how they were all getting squeezed by their college students, too.

Huh, I thought. My kid has never done that. How?

I asked my daughter about it

My daughter saved up from selling art in high school and lined up a job in dining services before she arrived at college, so I knew she'd have some spending money. But it never occurred to me that she'd think she had to pay for her own necessities.

Advertisement
Advertisement

So I asked her about it: "Hey, how come you don't ever ask me for money? How are you paying for school supplies and snacks and shampoo and stuff?"

"I'm OK!" she said. "I give myself a weekly budget of $100, and I don't really need more than that."

She didn't mind eating at the dining halls all the time and participated in clothing exchanges and thrift store shopping. She mentioned there were plenty of free activities on campus and a library full of books. When she didn't use her full weekly budget, she saved for concert tickets and gifts for friends.

I Venmoed her $50, just for kicks, and she sent back $20 of it. "That's too much!" she wrote.

I felt bad and wanted to fulfill my parental role to support my teenager

It had been a goal of mine as a single mom to provide for her through college so she'd never have that added stress.

Advertisement
Advertisement

That's when Sarina said something that helped me see things differently: "I like paying for my own stuff. It makes me feel like a responsible adult, you know?"

Actually, I did know — and I'd forgotten that feeling. When I went to college, my parents didn't want me to get a job or join clubs in the first year because they wanted me to focus only on my studies. But once I proved my grades were solid, they backed off, and by my senior year, I was working two jobs. It did feel good to earn my own money.

I took a more trusting approach with my daughter; I didn't set rules about how she should spend her time, but I asked her to keep a light work schedule until she settled in and could see what her college workload would be like.

Sarina was able to piece together a schedule that worked out fine, though, combining work and play in proportions that made her happy. She handled time management like a boss and ended the year with straight As.

Advertisement
Advertisement

This year, she's working in the mailroom during the week and as a local chocolate tour guide on weekends.

Every now and then, I still send her money

I know full well she'll often return part of it or limit what I'm "allowed" to send. I was allowed to pay for her train ticket home, for instance, but not for the Lyft ride to the station.

When I tried to pay her $90 for shoveling our driveway over break (the rate my usual company would have charged), she wouldn't take more than $50. It's a dance, both of us wanting to feel good about our contributions. Both of us gather some of our self-worth by our ability to work for what we want and need in life.

There is joy in self-reliance, in that burgeoning confidence you get when you realize you're capable of making your way in the world.

If you enjoyed this story, be sure to follow Business Insider on Yahoo.

Up next
Business Insider

I'm an American mom in Germany. I let my 8-year-old walk to school alone — other parents asked me why it took so long.

Kate Chrisman
4 min read
Add Yahoo on Google
Mom and son
The author let her son walk alone to school when he was 8.Courtesy of the author
  • German parents were shocked that I waited until third grade to let my son walk alone.

  • Watching local kids commute independently pushed me to rethink my parenting fears.

  • My son became more responsible almost immediately after gaining more independence.

The first time my 8-year-old walked to school alone, I watched him turn the corner and disappear. I kept picturing the busy street he had to cross — at just over four feet tall, would drivers see him?

But he made it to school that day, confirmed by a quick message from his smartwatch. And when he returned that afternoon on his own, he was glowing with pride.

Advertisement
Advertisement

We'd been thinking about when to let our oldest walk on his own for years. In first grade, it wasn't even an option. His school was a 3.5-mile bike ride or a 30-minute subway and bus trip. Then we moved within walking distance of campus, and suddenly, his question, "When can I walk by myself?" was harder to dodge.

We finally settled on third grade.

In Germany, kids walking alone is normal

By local standards, he should have been walking to school alone for at least a year. When I told a German friend he was walking to school alone, her response was: "Why so late?"

In our Berlin neighborhood, the streets fill with kids heading to school on their own each morning. In September, younger children walk with their parents. A few months in, many of those same kids are on their own. On the subway in the morning or mid-afternoon, I'll see someone barely four feet tall, backpack on, navigating their commute as confidently as an adult.

Child walking alone
The author quizzed her son before letting him to walk alone to school.Courtesy of the author

When I ask my German friends when they first let their kids go alone, the answers are consistently earlier than I expect. But German parents are also consciously training their children to be ready for this step, something we did too. Leading up to the big day, I'd had him lead the way over and over, making sure he wouldn't get lost. We also talked exhaustively about the crosswalk, and I quizzed him on how he knew it was safe to cross.

Advertisement
Advertisement

But as an American parent in Germany, not knowing exactly where my child was — even for a 15-minute walk — made me anxious.

What changed when he started walking alone

Within weeks of that first walk, his independence grew.

Instead of having to remind him to pack his snack and get dressed, he gets himself out the door on time. I'll come into the kitchen and find him already eating granola and yogurt. He finishes, puts his dishes in the dishwasher, and then packs his own snack. He hands me homework or tests that require a parent's signature, and then says goodbye.

At school, he sometimes makes plans with friends and lets me know if he'll be home later than normal. Sometimes I get a quick message: "I'm going to the playground." I've been surprised by how much I love hearing that.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Wearing the smartwatch and keeping it in good condition are conditions for his ability to go places independently. Watching him care for it, and sometimes misplace it, gives me a glimpse of what life will be like when he gets a cellphone — which I hope is still years down the road.

It changed our mornings, too

There was a shift for us as parents, too.

His school starts at 8:30 a.m.; his siblings' preschool (in the same building) starts at 9 a.m. Getting three kids out the door in time for the earlier start used to be a mad scramble.

Now, I can move at a slower pace with the younger two. Our daily routine includes reading a book as they get their shoes and jackets on, something we didn't have time for before.

Advertisement
Advertisement

And it makes logistics for juggling three kids' schedules easier too. After school activities have become easier to manage, as I'm just thinking about how to get two kids home instead of three.

I still worry

He's been walking on his own now for a year and a half. I still think about that crosswalk. But he comes home on time, full of stories, and with a confidence he's earned by doing things on his own.

Street in Germany
The author says her son is more capable than she gave him credit for.Courtesy of the author

And I've come to see that he's more capable than I gave him credit for.

His independence doesn't go unnoticed by his younger siblings; my six-year-old longs for the day he can stay at home alone, or run an errand to the grocery store for us, or walk to school without his parents. We're not there yet.

If you enjoyed this story, be sure to follow Business Insider on Yahoo.

Up next
Bolde

I’m 44, and I keep watching my friends parent their kids like it’s the most important job in the world, and what I want to tell them is that my Boomer parents treated it like the third most important thing in their lives, and I think I’m better off because of it

Bolde Team
6 min read
Add Yahoo on Google

A friend of mine recently asked me, completely sincerely, whether I thought her son was showing early signs of anxiety because he didn't like raising his hand in class.

He's seven. There is nothing different or wrong about him. He's just a regular, quiet seven-year-old.

But she'd been reading, and now there was a worry, and the worry had a kind of full-time quality to it that I recognized in a lot of my friends.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Now, I love my friends. I think they're amazing parents, more thoughtful than mine ever tried to be. But somewhere in the last decade or two, the job of parent has changed shape in a big way. It stopped being something you do and became something you are — a whole identity, monitored and graded and never quite finished.

And I keep having this thought I can't say at the group dinners, where everyone's comparing notes on screens and snacks and whether to hold the kid back a year. My parents treated raising me like maybe the third most important thing in their lives. Behind their marriage. Behind their work. Roughly tied with the garden.

And I think it's the reason I turned out steady. I think it's why I can sit alone in a room and not need anyone to tell me how I'm doing in it.

They loved me. They just didn't orbit me.

boomers with their kids in the 80s
Image via Bolde

"Third most important thing" sounds like a complaint, and it isn't. My parents were great. They showed up for the big stuff. But they had whole lives churning underneath mine — friends, jobs, a marriage with its own private weather — and they never once acted like I was the center of the household.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Dinner was at six. Not "six unless you're not hungry." Not a separate plate for the picky kid. Six.

Friday nights belonged to them, and I got a sitter who let me watch things I was far too young to watch. When I was bored, that was my problem. Nobody scheduled anything to solve it. Boredom was just what Sundays felt like.

You never notice it while it's happening. But being handed a little benign neglect meant I had to do something with myself, and doing something with myself, over and over in small unimpressive ways, is how I slowly came to believe I could handle being a person. I'm not sure there's another route to that belief. I think you mostly have to be left alone enough to find it.


Related: People born between 1965 and 1985 carry these 10 emotional habits from their childhood that younger generations will never quite understand


The hovering doesn't even work, which is what gets me

You'd assume more attention makes a more secure kid — more eyes on them, more support, more love made visible. It mostly does the opposite.

Advertisement
Advertisement

A psychologist at the University of Mary Washington ran a study that people keep coming back to. She looked at college students whose parents were still managing the small print of their lives, and those students weren't flourishing — they reported more depression and less satisfaction with their lives, and what sat underneath it was a missing sense of autonomy.

If nobody ever lets you steer, you don't end up feeling safe. You end up feeling like you can't drive.

I felt a little smug reading that, and then bad about the smugness, because my friends aren't running experiments, they're just tired people who love their kids and got handed a culture that told them love means vigilance. But the finding is stubborn, and it shows up again and again.

Being attended to that completely can leave a kid feeling weirdly unconnected — handled rather than known. Which is the cruel little twist of the whole thing, because it was love the entire time. It just got delivered as management.

The kid catches the parent's anxiety

Kids are antennae. They pick up the signal whether or not you mean to send it.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Developmental research has shown how the pressure to stay endlessly switched-on produces real, measurable stress, and how, strangely, anxious parents tend to become more withdrawn and less responsive in exactly the moments they're working hardest to be present.

So the harder you grip, the less available you sometimes are.

My mother, by contrast, was out in the yard most Saturdays, half-listening to whatever catastrophe I was narrating, pulling weeds. I hated it sometimes. I wanted the full beam of her attention, and I didn't always get it.

But she was modeling something I had no words for then: that a person can love you and still be calm. That your small disaster is not the building on fire. Kids who grow up around that calm tend to borrow it. Kids who grow up around a hum of low-grade parental dread tend to borrow that instead.

What kids need isn't more, it's warmth with room in it

Image via Bolde
Image via Bolde

I'm not arguing for neglect, to be clear — distance has its own costs, and I'd be lying if I called my parents' style a deliberate philosophy rather than, partly, the fashion of their decade.

Advertisement
Advertisement

But what I got, almost by accident, was warmth with space left inside it. They were around without being fused to me. They cared without supervising.

And I've come to think the space was the active ingredient. Not the warmth alone, which everybody's got in surplus right now, but the daylight around it — the boredom nobody rushed to cure, the small problems nobody swooped in on, the afternoons where the adult in charge was busy with her own life and I had to become the adult in charge of mine.

That gap is where I learned the thing I most want for my friends' kids: that I could be left alone and the world would hold.

You can't hand a child that lesson directly. You can only step back far enough that they get to discover it themselves.


Related: 13 old-school rules boomers still live by that make zero sense anymore


I think we confused attention with love

Somewhere in my generation's very decent wish to do better than our parents, I think a wire crossed.

Advertisement
Advertisement

We decided that more attention equals more love, so maximum attention must equal maximum love. But they're not the same currency. You can flood a kid with the first and accidentally shortchange them on the trust that the second actually runs on.

My parents trusted me to be fine. It was occasionally maddening — there were absolutely nights I wished they'd noticed more, pushed more, hovered even a little. But the slow accumulated effect of being trusted is that you start, almost against your will, to suspect you might be trustworthy. You build a self that keeps running when the parent leaves the room.

I don't say any of this at the dinners.

What I want to tell my friends is that the love was never in doubt, and the vigilance was never the proof of it. That they're allowed to have a life their kid revolves around, instead of the other way around. That the kid is going to be fine — better than fine — and that one of the most generous things they could do is close the laptop, go to bed, and let him be a little more on his own than feels comfortable.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Not because they love him too much. Because the kind of love that loosens its grip might be the exact kind he needs.

Editor's Note: "As Told to Bolde" stories are inspired by reader submissions, interviews, and accounts shared with our editorial team. Details are often changed, combined, or dramatized, and our editors use AI tools in the writing process. See our Editorial Policy.

Submit your stories submissions@thebolde.com

Advertisement