The Guardian be like…
Best
Open comment sort options
Best
Top
New
Controversial
Old
Q&A
The real Great Replacement has been replacing actual journalists with mass produced government knob-gobblers who can't think critically to save their lives
You can thank the switch from information driven to narrative driven news stories.
I think credentialism is actually what destroyed journalism. You'll never learn how to be a good journalist at a university, and I think the extremely low quality of modern journalists is a testament to this
I like how I read a while back a journalist saying she wants a country where almost everyone is a shade of brown and that would be a utopia.
Brazil is basically an entire shade of brown.
We are 100% not a utopia.
It's okay to say that white people will be a minority in Western nations as long as you say it's a good thing, but if you say it's a bad thing, you're an evil, racist conspiracy theorist and that is completely and totally false.
There's a term for this that was coined in an essay some years back: celebration parallax ("parallax" is the phenomenon whereby an object appears different to the viewer depending on their point of view). The tl;dr version is, "the same fact pattern is either true and glorious or false and scurrilous depending on who states it".
Y’know this is maybe gonna be unpopular but I think a good example of this is Luigi Mangione.
To his supporters he is simultaneously a hero for killing someone, and also he didn’t kill anyone.
If you say he killed someone you’re told it’s true if you support that, and it’s not true if you don’t.
The west is so self hating. It is insufferable.
Imagine living in Japan or South Korea and white people coming in such droves that Asians start to become a minority and believing it is somehow a good thing.
We really need to smarten the fuck up.
If you're white you get no "homeland" everywhere white people come from is treated like the US. German isn't an ethnicity like Chinese or Indian is, it's just a person born in Germany in a way that isn't the case in China or India. A north African born in Germany is told they're German but they aren't any more German than they would be if they were born in China and told they're Chinese.
Also remember there is one single group of indigenous people in Europe the Sami of Sweden. White people must have arrived in spaceships I guess.
Pretty sure it was Yakub
The right called it replacement theory, the left called it demographic destiny and the media called it the 'Browning of America'.
The New Europeans
This looks like one of those slightly caricaturized AI “photos”. I’m not saying it is one. It just has that aesthetic.
I'd be far more okay with this if military recruitment ads highlighted the new Europeans. If they're just as European as everyone else surely they are ready to fight Russia/Iran in order to protect their homeland right?
Also the UK gov: "The countryside is too white"
Spain gov: "We literally want immigrants to vote to suppress the right wing"
The US gov (sometimes): "States aren't allowed to stop people coming across the Mexican border. States dont get to choose whether they want immigration, thats federal"
Also the US gov (sometimes): "The federal government isn't allowed to remove illegal immigrants in states that don't want it, states should have the choice over immigration"
Most of the other comments in the thread so far, are about whether this immigration is "natural" or "artificial/deliberate/caused by the government". Consider this as you read them.
North Korea: "Why aren't we getting more South Koreans across the border?"
Better build a taller flag pole!
Population replacement is THE most blatant of all the "It's not happening and it's a good thing that it is!" leftist gaslights.
I'm telling you, the joke will be on the left, at least in the US, because after the 2nd generation Hispanics vote very similarly to non historic white people.
To be fair, Great Replacement theory claims it's a global conspiracy, while it's more likely to be a short-sighted migration policy.
Then why do I get called a conspiracy theorist for saying that the unfettered immigration is replacing the native people?
Because in modern discourse you are always conflated with the most retarded side of any issue, regardless of how you actually feel about it
My province was 93% European in 1961 (the second largest group was Asians, mostly Hong Kong born Chinese, at about 4%)
Over 80% of those of European heritage were English, Irish, Welsh, or Scottish.
This had been the case since the 1850's
It was 85% European in in 1981, and then by 1991 that number dropped to 51% with only 22% being from the UK
Today, only 8.2% of the population has British heritage while 23.6% are Chinese, 14% are Indian, 9.2% are Filipino, etc.
In Vancouver, a whopping 54.5% are a now "visible minority"... that number was 13.9% in 1981
Anyone who has lived through this period, as I have, can tell you this demographic shift has had a profound and negative effect on the community and cultural landscape of the province - we are no longer a united people, with a shared identity and common norms and values, but rather a scattering of cultural enclaves divided by language, religion, and perspective.
Heck, we don't even celebrate our holidays anymore.
Self hating liberal white people will really be the downfall of the west
reminds me of the book "The Camp of the Saints"
Some non-whites have compatible values and it's silly to put them in the same bag as you-know-who (i.e islamists that play victim until they reach majority and impose shariah as constitution).
I think skin colour is an information but it is not what truly matters.
I'm particularly cool with Catholics from certain Central or Southern American countries; fantastic work ethic, western values, delicious food, etc.
Many of them learned the value of capitalism and democracy the hard way... you ever worked with a Cuban? They're amazing!
Truly amazing that this is only a problem happening in majority european countries. If this was happening anywhere else, they would hang the entire goverment.
I mean whites put themselves in a losing situation because they only consider pure white people to be white. If a white and a non white have a child, the child isnt considered white.
This is a consequence of race being pseudoscience nonsense anyways.
I don't know why people call it a conspiracy theory. It's statistical fact at this point. We have enough data from the past 100 years to conclusively determine that demographic change in the west is happening quite quickly, and the proportion of whites in their own countries is shrinking.
We can discuss the causes, or what this means, but there is no debate or argument to be had about whether or not it is happening. It IS happening.
They label you as a “Great Replacement Theorist” to make you look bad for pointing it out. It’s similar to labeling people as "Nazis" for not wanting uncontrolled immigration.
I believe there is a big difference between saying that a demographic change exists and claiming that this change is somehow orchestrated by the Freemasons, the Illuminati, or whoever
Ermmm actually epstein caused it because an anonymous tip said so in the files