1) ...and now to your first query. TSR controlled the storylines of the published Realms, but if we were starting over and I was given that control, I would avoid all RSEs (Realms-Shaking Events) like the Time of Troubles, Spellplague, and Second Sundering. #realmslore
hail and good fortune to you @TheEdVerse I have two questions for you 1] supposing you had been invited to work on a rebooted forgotten realms that and had started again from the year of the Prince [aka the grey box] would you change anything as far as the continuity developed?

Jul 16, 2024 · 9:15 PM UTC

14
28
326
35,974
2) Big changes would only happen with lots of foreshadowing/buildup in many published releases, and only after we'd covered the entire surface world, and a good bit of the Underdark and celestial (Tears of Selune, etc.) Realms, too, at least once over. Build up... #realmslore
1
1
93
2,131
3) ...before you tear down. There were also things I never got the chance to do (completed detailed city? Ath Cliath, which I'm doing with Andrew Valkauskas and Mike Schley for #FateOfTheNorns right now, because I never got the wordcount to do it with Waterdeep...or Suzail, or..)
1
1
84
2,025
4) ...and many DM's campaign toolbox releases (the Haunted Halls was supposed to be 96 pages and completely detail Eveningstar, not 32 pages and just do highlights of the Halls, likewise Undermountain). Moreover, Books and Games would work together closely, so what.. #realmslore
2
2
85
3,301
5) ...authors craft for novels are fully described in game terms with the authors approval and involvement, so the Realms can really grow in all directions with each writer getting proper treatment. And so on. This is a big topic. ;} #realmslore
4
4
102
3,152
Replying to @TheEdVerse
Do you feel like the Realms has diverged substantially over time from your original imagination of it, due to these sorts of events?
2
10
1,300
Not really. Grown, yes, diverged not so much. I've stayed involved, feeding lore to every creative I can, so I have been able to do a little steering from behind the scenes, and except for the RSEs, we're still exploring my original, seeing more and deeper...
49
1,219
Replying to @TheEdVerse
Always glad to hear your perspective and take on things. The Time of Troubles is still one of my favorite reads, though, from that time. I tell people to this day to find copies of Shadowdale, Tantras and Waterdeep if they can or offer to lend them my paperbacks.
4
566
Replying to @TheEdVerse
So interesting that you would avoid the RSEs. They never sat well with me, and I had omitted them from my Forgotten Realms 3.5HD homebrew setting. 😎👍 Thank you Forgotten Realms @TheEdVerse , I escape there often. 🧙‍♂️🔮
3
597
Replying to @TheEdVerse
Big hug for this. I think continuity is the fuel that runs any fiction, including the kind we spin using RPGs as the medium. Once you establish that something happened, or something works a certain way, retconning it yanks everyone out of their suspension of disbelief.
1
21
Replying to @TheEdVerse
You take on writing novels and game materials for full campaign settings is exactly the thought I've always had for writing for campaign settings. It only makes sense.
1
73
Replying to @TheEdVerse
Can we get a 1357 DR reset? I need to correct... er... some decisions I made in Waterdeep with a certain elf with the initials EC.
1
117
Replying to @TheEdVerse
But about those cheeses....?
1
58
Replying to @TheEdVerse
Brilliant stuff my friend, and this is why you will always be one of my inspirations.
174
Replying to @TheEdVerse
Yes! I do exactly that in my own variant of the Realms! Thrilling to know you and I are on the same page.
104
Replying to @TheEdVerse
No Time of Troubles? I’m fascinated to think about what the Realms would be like without it.
65
Replying to @TheEdVerse
The Time of Troubles was cool.
101
Replying to @TheEdVerse
I just ignored them. I never used the changes those events created.
78
Replying to @TheEdVerse
Very interesting. How would you handle an edition change then? Just purely mechanical?
144